Why Citizens Insurance’s DOAH Endorsement Should Alarm Florida Homeowners — And What You Must Do Now

TL;DR – What Florida Homeowners Must Know About Citizens Insurance’s DOAH Endorsement

1. New DOAH Endorsement Limits Your Rights: Citizens Insurance can now force disputes into binding arbitration through DOAH, taking away your right to a jury trial and limiting your ability to recover full damages.
2. Arbitration Favors the Insurer: DOAH is a fast-tracked process that benefits Citizens, with limited discovery, no jury, no attorney fees, and minimal appeal options.
3. Appraisal Is Your Best Move: Invoking appraisal immediately after coverage is opened can block DOAH and give you a fairer chance at recovery.
4. Real-Life Case Gone Wrong: A homeowner received under $1,000 after a hurricane. Their case was derailed by DOAH until Panther Public Adjusting stepped in—but it was a much harder battle than it needed to be.
5. Don’t Wait—Act Now: Contact Panther Public Adjusting right away to review your Citizens policy and prepare your claim strategy before disaster strikes.

Understanding the Game-Changer in Citizens Insurance Policies

If you’re a Florida homeowner insured by Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, there’s a critical change you need to know about — the introduction of the DOAH (Division of Administrative Hearings) endorsement in new policy language. This isn’t just legal fine print. It could severely limit your ability to get a fair insurance claim settlement.

Let us walk you through what this means, why it’s stacked against you, and how hiring a public adjuster from day one can make or break your claim. And if you’re in cities like Sarasota, Tampa, or Saint Petersburg, this insight could be the difference between a denied claim and a full payout.

---

What Is the DOAH Endorsement?

Citizens Insurance now includes a new endorsement that pushes disputes into mandatory arbitration through the Division of Administrative Hearings (DOAH) rather than allowing them to go to court with a jury.

This endorsement is titled:

ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION — DIVISION OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS (CIT DP 03 15 10 23)

This endorsement gives Citizens Insurance the opportunity that if you file a Notice of Intent (NOI) to litigate, Citizens can instead avoid fair litigation, and instead force the matter into DOAH arbitration. Here’s why that’s a problem:

• You lose your right to a jury trial.
• The process is fast-tracked but not in your favor.
• Arbitration is final and binding with limited appeal rights.
• Attorney fees are not awarded under this process.

---

Why DOAH Is a Problem for Policyholders

DOAH proceedings are not designed to protect you. They are streamlined, limited in scope, and generally favor insurers who are more experienced in the administrative law setting. Here’s what makes them a bad deal for homeowners:

• No discovery leverage: Your attorney has limited tools to uncover the insurer’s internal documentation.
• No jury of your peers: Just one administrative law judge (ALJ) decides your fate.
• Limited damage recovery: While this is relatively new, results so far seem to be in favor of Citizens, and not in the Homeowners best interest.
• Speed over justice: Hearings are often scheduled quickly, not giving your side enough time to build a comprehensive case.

Bottom line: The deck is stacked against you.

For more insights on why a public adjuster is your best first move, check out 4 Myths About Public Adjusting.

---

The Real-Life Cost: A Hurricane Milton Claim Gone Sideways

Here’s a story that illustrates the risks:

After Hurricane Milton, a Florida homeowner filed a claim with Citizens. Coverage was opened, and they were paid less than $1,000 after their deductible. Not knowing any better, they hired an attorney who filed the required NOI.

Citizens immediately invoked DOAH.

The original attorney realized he was out of his depth and dropped the case. That’s when their friends told them to reach out to Panther Public Adjusting like they did. We helped document the claim properly, and connected the homeowner with competent legal help. But even with our assistance, the process became unnecessarily complicated and prolonged.

Had this homeowner invoked appraisal the moment coverage was opened, they could have avoided DOAH altogether and resolved the claim faster and more fairly.

---

Appraisal: Your Best Weapon Against DOAH

Here’s the key strategy: invoke appraisal immediately when Citizens opens coverage, even if it’s below your deductible.

Why? Because:

• Once appraisal is elected, Citizens cannot force DOAH.
• Appraisal is faster and more neutral.
• You avoid binding arbitration that limits your rights.

Even if Citizens denies your claim, invoking appraisal can block them from later invoking DOAH and forces the case into regular court where you can demand a jury trial.

For more guidance, read How a Public Adjuster Turned $40K Into $400K for a Commercial Claim.

---

The Time to Act Is Now

Don’t wait until it’s too late. If Citizens opens coverage on your claim, your window to take action is limited. Here’s what you should do:

Step 1: Contact Panther Public Adjusting Immediately

We know how to fight Citizens and navigate around DOAH. ✅ Contact us now ✅ Or call us today at 833-726-8437

Step 2: Email Your Policy for Review

Don’t wait until after a loss. Let us analyze your Citizens policy before disaster strikes. ✅ Email: Claims@PantherPA.com

Step 3: Educate Yourself and Stay Connected

Join our community to stay ahead of the curve:

• Subscribe to our YouTube channel, My Insurance Claim Expert
• Join our Facebook group, Anything About Property Insurance Claims 101

---

Florida Homeowners, Don’t Let This Happen to You

If you’re in Miami, Ruskin, or Palmetto, and you suffer property damage, your Citizens policy could lead you straight into a DOAH hearing. Don’t let it. Here’s how you can prepare:

• Get a free policy review today: Claims@PantherPA.com
• Speak to our experts: 833-726-8437

---

Don’t Take Chances With Citizens

With Citizens’ new DOAH endorsement in play, you need more than just insurance—you need strategic representation.

Let Panther Public Adjusting be your shield. We’ll ensure your claim is prepared from day one to avoid DOAH, push for appraisal, and, if necessary, fight in court for a jury trial.

Read more: Avoid This Common Insurance Check Trap — Your Money Could Be at Risk

Still unsure? Explore What Happens to My Policy When I File a Claim

---

Take Action Now

✅ Contact us directly at PantherPA.com ✅ Call now: 833-726-8437 ✅ Email your policy for a complimentary review: Claims@PantherPA.com

With offices across Florida and an unmatched passion for protecting homeowners, Panther Public Adjusting is your first and strongest line of defense.

Don’t gamble with your home, your claim, or your future. Partner with us today.